The Green Bay Packers traded Brett Favre to the New York Jets for a very, very conditional draft pick. The Packers currently receive a fourth-round pick, but if Favre plays 50% of the snaps in New York, the pick turns to a third-round pick. If Favre plays 70% of the snaps and the Jets make the playoffs, the Pack receive a second-rounder and if Favre plays 80% of the snaps and the Jets make the Super Bowl, Green Bay gets a–you guessed it–first round pick.
So now that the ordeal is over, excluding the continuous reporting of it for a day or two just so no one would miss out on the news, it’s time to look at what it all means for everyone involved, directly and indirectly.
Green Bay Packers
What it Means
It’s hard to draw positives from the fact that a team just lost an iconic legend, but given the situation, it was something the Packers had to do. Months and months of him tinkering with the idea on retirement or, in this case, actually going through with it all, drove the team further away from focusing on camp and the future of the franchise. Favre just backed himself into a corner by officially retiring.
This is not a weight lifted off the Packers’ shoulders just yet. Sure, Favre is gone from Green Bay, but he’s not gone from the NFL.
What If…
…Brett never oficially retired? I doubt the Packers’ could have presented an open QB competition for Rodgers, let alone turn the team over to him. Favre got itchy at the beginning of July. If he still remained on the roster without retiring, the Packers would have #4 starting at quarterback. I always had it in my mind that the Packers should trade Aaron Rodgers while he still had potential and value, keep Brett Favre, and groom Brian Brohm for the future. Though, to be fair, I never put it down on paper (aka blogged it), so I have to give credit to Matt Snyder from AOL Fanhouse for covering the same topic.
… what if Favre can still put up numbers that are far superior to the stats of Aaron Rodgers? Then the Packers don’t look so hot. However, they have plenty of time to organize the “We made a decision and we had to keep our word. Sure, Aaron Rodgers threw 15 less touchdowns and one less interception than Favre, but he is our man for the future” bit before season’s end.
For the Packers, regardless of Favre’s play, they can come back to the “But you gotta see it from our perspective…” story and I really can’t blame them. They did announce an open QB competition, but Favre wasn’t interested. That leads me to beleive the competition was a hoax, which, in that case, allows me to blame the Packers for losing a legend.
New York Jets
What it Means
This Favre trade means the Jets now have a capable quarterback, can give Kellen Clemens a quarterback to learn from, and can trade Chad Pennington to the Kansas City Chiefs. The trade also means Brady vs. Favre twice a year. Ugh. All the hype is going to drive me nuts. The Pats will stomp them both times anyway.
What If…
…the Favre Experiment flames out? Who cares? They lose a fourth round pick. If he plays half of the year for them, which I expect it to be more, they lose a third rounder. I’m sure the Jets wouldn’t mind giving up a round two pick for making the playoffs behind Favre. Makes them look like geniuses–or genii if you prefer. And obtaining a quarterback for 80 percent of your teams’ snaps and getting a Super Bowl appearance out of it, move over Albert, Mangini is coming your way.
I see no negatives from this deal for the Jets. If it doesn’t work, they still have Clemens and the ability to say they gave it a shot. Anyone can make a case for the media’s affect on a team atmosphere, but it’s the New York Jets. Even though they’re more of the New Jersey Jets, they still get a fair share of New York spotlight. This is still an improvement on the current quarterback situation and it leaves the team with an option for a future quarterback. Sounds like the Packers, eh?
Tampa Bay Buccaneers
What it Means
Nothing, really. They don’t gamble on Favre and yes, it would have been a gamble for the Bucs. John Gruden wants to control his quarterback; Favre wants to have control over the team. Jeff Garcia takes care of the ball and the Bucs’ defense win the games. Let’s just say Favre doesn’t have a “play-it-safe” mentality.
What If…
…the Bucs pulled the trigger on the deal and offered the Packers enough? Welp, tempers would flare between Gruden and Favre and the team, which has a real shot at the NFC South, could unravel at the seams. Also, the speedy Joey Galloway’s fantasy stock would rise on my board because of Favre’s cannon. Good thing I didn’t trade for Galloway yesterday like I thought I should…
It just seems that Tampa is better off without Favre to me.
Minnesota Vikings
What it Means
The Vikings not getting Favre makes them look less guilty of tampering, even though they were already found not guilty earlier this week. It also means Tarvaris Jackson is the man in Minnesota…well at quarterback at least. The Vikings now don’t have to face Favre twice a year and they get to rough up on a young quarterback, which gives the Vikes a much better shot at winning the NFC North.
What If…
…the Vikings somehow got ahold of Favre? Of course the Packers weren’t trading inside the division, but just go with it.
Vikings: “Hello, Mr. Favre. Meet Minnesota.”
Brad Childress: “Hello, Mr. Favre. Meet Adrian Peterson, Bernard Berrian, and a stingy defense.”
Me: “Hola, Señor Favre. Meet the Super Bowl. Meet is such a weird looking word. M-e-e-t? Haha. It’s just one of those words…”
Also, Bernard Berrian follows the Joey Galloway logic.
Chicago Bearsss
What it Means
Rex Grossman vs. Kyle Orton: Battle for Mediocrity. Unless they learn to utilize Devin Hester on the screen pass, the Bears will finish third in the NFC North.
What If…
…the Bears got Favre?
Bears: “Hello, Mr. Favre. Meet Chicago.”
Lovie Smith: “Hello, Mr. Favre. Meet Adrian Peterson, Devin Hester, and a still pretty good defense.”
Me: “Hey, Brett. That’s not the good Adrian Peterson, that’s the other one, so don’t get your hopes up. Hester is a speedster and you have a good defense behind you. Uhh…I wouldn’t grant you a Super Bowl bid yet…not even guarantee the playoffs. Heh…speaking of meeting people, the word itself…..”
The NFL
What it Means
The NFL can now get back to what it does in the pre-season. Play meaningless games and report on who has a hamstring injury (It seems like everyone does right now. That’s what we in the business call a ploy to not have to play pre-season games.).
What If…
…Roger Goodell didn’t re-instate Favre? He’d be hated by many, loved by few, and cement his legacy as a total hard ass.
The Media
What it Means
There is going to be a lull in the media world of sports. They can report as much as they want on how Favre is doing at camp, but no one will be glued to his TV anymore like I was once the re-instatement was granted. They’ll be all over it once the season draws nearer and nearer, though.
What If…
…Favre’s itch went away as soon as it came? We’d be bombarded with stories of Chinese Human Rights issues, a 40-year old swimmer, the Men’s Basketball team, “Why you should watch Olympic archery” and “What to watch for during a fencing match” stories, and team-by-team breakdowns of Little League World Series teams and in-depth coverage of how to effectively push your child into reaching goals you never could acheive while making him hate competitive sports, and possibly you, while doing so.
ESPN
What it Means
It’s time to pick up on the things mentioned above.
What if…
…the saga of Brett Favre was still happening?
Hello, launch of ESPN 4: Brett Favre 24/7.